Joao Aguirre, Ph.D.Español
← Blog

The “honourable people” who think they are PhDs: doctoritis

A few years ago, I went to teach a master's class at Universidad Externado. For the first session I dressed casually: jeans, a T-shirt and Converse. I was outside the traditional dress code, but it was part of a small social experiment.

I introduced myself: “Hello, I am Dr Joao Aguirre, and I will be teaching this course.” Some looked incredulous, some laughed and others ignored me completely. I picked up a marker, wrote my name on the board, then perched defiantly on the teacher's desk, folded my arms and waited. Most continued what they were doing, and I became more serious with every passing minute. Eventually, a couple of students approached: “Are you really our teacher?” I nodded. “Seriously?” I kept nodding. “I don't believe you,” one student said. A diligent but equally sceptical student searched my name online, found a photograph and announced: “Everyone, he really is the teacher!” Some were bewildered, others repeated the question and a few tried to quieten their classmates so I could begin.

After briefly intimidating them by filling the board with concepts, equations and seemingly complicated material, I stopped and asked why they had not believed I was the teacher. Their answers varied: “You are too young to have a doctorate”; “You look like another student”; “You don't look like a doctor.” I asked what a doctor should look like. “Obviously,” one replied, “someone in a suit and tie.”

It is sad to see how the concept of “doctor” has been distorted, particularly in Colombian and Mexican society. Almost anyone wearing a suit and tie is called doctor, regardless of whether they work in a public or private organisation. The suit inspires admiration and deferential respect. “Welcome, doctor”; “Come in, doctor”; “What would you like to drink, doctor?” There are countless flattering expressions that secretaries, guards, messengers, drivers and subordinates direct at this select group.

After the demanding studies that took me almost eight years to complete my doctorate, I personally feel uncomfortable being called doctor. The word has lost the respect and value that should reflect the considerable effort involved in research and study at this level.

I see it as an illness spreading through every social level. Some use the title to elevate their boss or the person who gives them work. In the exclusive upper social circles it proliferates even more. I have noticed some of the worst symptoms in government institutions and among lawyers.

I will never forget visiting a law office in Colombia before I had finished my doctorate. As I was introduced around the office, I felt as if I were at CERN or a similar research centre: I had never seen so many doctors together. “This is Dr Cáceres, and this is Dr Sánchez, and over here is Dr Ramírez…” The list went on. Not even at Universidad Nacional, where I studied, had I seen so many doctors in one office. And because status apparently comes through inheritance, I also met “Dr Carlos”, about nineteen years old, who was only beginning his law degree at a prestigious university but was already called doctor because he was the owner's son.

This epidemic of doctoritis began to give me an aversion to a title I should feel proud of. As my father says, earning that academic degree is something to hold your head high about. Unfortunately, society is so affected by doctoritis that I now introduce myself simply by my first name and, when relevant, add PhD, the abbreviation for Doctor of Philosophy.

Doctoritis is damaging our society. On one side are people who want to make others feel important, which is understandable to a point. On the other are those who pretend to be something they are not. These are the worst: they want to feel superior and demand to be called DOCTOR, complete with special deference.

I have met a few people with that degree of arrogance. They introduce themselves by saying, “Pleased to meet you, I am Dr Pepito Pérez.” Once, I replied: “Excellent, a colleague! Tell me, what was the central argument of your dissertation before the doctoral examination panel?” Silence. “Sorry?” he replied. “I don't understand. I'm not that kind of doctor.” “Then are you the kind who can write a medical prescription?” “No, not that either!” “Then what kind of doctor are you?” I asked. “Just call me doctor, full stop.” I remembered him as one of the HP doctors; remember, HP stands here for “honourable people”.

It is worth recalling those extraordinary Colombian stories in which someone shining shoes in the city centre obtains a government position and, overnight, magically becomes “the honourable Dr So-and-so”.

Every politician who enters office seems to be christened doctor. Every lawyer feels disrespected without it. Every sufficiently senior public servant feels entitled to the title. Let us change that and challenge this illness. Doctoritis is chronic, and although a vaccine exists, curing it will not be easy. We can begin by bringing down to earth those who feel superior because of a label before their name.

At the time of writing, I had been living in Australia for about three years. To my surprise, one of my deeply held assumptions was challenged: in my experience here, addressing someone by their professional title, such as teacher, engineer or even doctor, could feel belittling. Labelling a person solely by their studies seemed to diminish their identity as a human being.

Using a title before someone's name could sound ironic or dismissive. This was a significant culture shock for me, as Latin Americans grow up addressing people as teacher or professor. Here I found that people preferred to be addressed by name, and some felt offended by titles, as happened to me on occasion. The major exception I observed was “Professor”, awarded to someone with a doctorate and extensive experience. In those cases it conveyed respect; in the other situations I encountered, titles could cause offence.

I invite everyone to remove these labels and stop calling those “honourable people” doctors when the title merely inflates their egos.

P.S. The names and surnames above were changed out of respect for the honourable doctors.

Your comment

Your email stays private. Verify it to submit your comment for review.

Keep exploring.

A conversation starts here

Let’s talk.

Step 1 of 3

What brings you here?